In August of 2017, Hailey and Justin potentially crossed pathsonce that she and Justin were dating, but clarified they were not an exclusive couple. "We are not an exclusive couple,” she toldE! News Will Honor Luke Perry and Fred Andrews in Season 4 Premiere February 2016: Justin muses about marrying Hailey.In February 2016, Hailey met Justin’screwin San Francisco. Shortly after, she finallyconfirmed